Gyne Robot Surg Search

CLOSE


Gyne Robot Surg > Volume 7(2); 2026 > Article
Kim, Han, Choi, Seon, Kim, Kim, Lee, Kim, Song, Lee, Lee, Lee, Koo, Jung, Noh, Kim, Song, and Kwon: Single-port surgery as a surgical platform: the K-SPS roadmap framework for terminology, description, and ergonomics

Abstract

Single-port surgery (SPS) has evolved across laparoscopic and robotic technologies, yet its conceptual identity, terminology, and technical descriptions remain heterogeneous. The Korean Society of Single-Port Surgery initiated the K-SPS Roadmap Project to establish a common conceptual and descriptive framework for SPS. Expert discussions, formal voting, and simulator-based technical demonstrations were conducted during the K-SPS Roadmap Workshop. SPS was conceptualized as a surgical platform defined by single-site access rather than by a specific surgical system or commercial technology. Within this access-based framework, distinct access concepts, including the transabdominal single-port platform and vaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery, can be distinguished from the laparoscopic or robotic systems used to perform surgery. Accordingly, a hierarchical nomenclature of Platform–System–Procedure was proposed to distinguish the fundamental access configuration from the technological system and the surgical operation performed. The use of “SP” as the preferred terminology and the Platform–System–Procedure hierarchy received 90.3% and 93.8% support, respectively. Descriptive review of simulator-session recordings identified recurring variations in surgeon posture, port configuration, and instrument grip, including perpendicular and rotated trunk-orientation patterns, six port configuration patterns, and conventional and reverse grip patterns for the left-hand instrument. These observations were not intended to define an optimal technique but to identify fundamental variables for describing how SPS is performed. The K-SPS framework provides a technology-neutral and extensible language for describing, comparing, teaching, and systematically investigating SPS, and may provide a foundation for future ergonomic evaluation, surgical education, and multicenter research.

INTRODUCTION

Single-port surgery (SPS) has evolved substantially since its introduction into modern minimally invasive surgery. Initially developed as a laparoscopic approach using a single incision or access site, SPS has been applied across multiple surgical specialties and to a wide range of operative procedures. Advances in access devices, laparoscopic instruments, imaging systems, and robotic technology have further expanded the technical possibilities of surgery through a single access site [1,2].
Despite this evolution, the conceptual framework of SPS has remained fragmented. Multiple terms, including SPS, single-incision laparoscopic surgery, laparoendoscopic single-site surgery (LESS), and single-port (SP) access surgery, have been used to describe overlapping surgical approaches [1]. At the same time, the emergence of dedicated robotic SP systems has introduced a new distinction between laparoscopic and robotic approaches, raising a fundamental question of whether SPS should be defined by the surgical technology used or by the underlying mode of surgical access.
Technical descriptions of SPS are similarly heterogeneous. The convergence of the laparoscope and operative instruments through a single access site creates geometric and ergonomic characteristics that differ fundamentally from those of conventional multiport laparoscopy [2]. However, surgeon posture, instrument arrangement, hand–instrument interaction, and operative strategies are rarely described using a standardized framework. Consequently, techniques developed by experienced SPS surgeons may remain individualized and difficult to communicate, compare, or reproduce.
These limitations have implications beyond terminology. Without a shared conceptual and technical language, comparison between studies becomes difficult, surgical education remains dependent on individual experience, and multicenter investigation of SPS techniques and ergonomics is constrained. As surgical systems continue to evolve, a framework based solely on existing devices or technologies may become increasingly inadequate. Moreover, the development of established alternative access concepts, such as vaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (vNOTES), further highlights the need to distinguish the surgical access platform from the technological system used within it.
The Korean Society of Single-Port Surgery (KSSPS) therefore initiated the K-SPS Roadmap Project to establish a conceptual, terminological, and ergonomic framework for SPS. Through expert discussion, formal voting, and simulator-based observation during the K-SPS Roadmap Workshop, the project sought to reconsider SPS from the perspective of its underlying surgical platform and to identify fundamental variables that characterize SPS.
This White Paper proposes a platform-based conceptual framework for SPS, introduces a hierarchical nomenclature based on Platform–System–Procedure, and describes ergonomic and technical patterns observed among experienced SPS surgeons. Rather than defining a single ideal technique, the framework aims to provide a common language for describing, comparing, teaching, and systematically investigating SPS across surgical systems and technologies.

DEVELOPMENT OF THE K-SPS FRAMEWORK

The KSSPS convened the K-SPS Roadmap Workshop on April 5, 2026, at Samsung Medical Center, Seoul, Republic of Korea. The workshop brought together surgeons with experience in SPS to discuss the conceptual and technical issues that have emerged as SPS has evolved across surgical specialties and technologies (Fig. 1).
The framework presented in this White Paper was primarily developed through two focused areas of discussion: the conceptual and terminological standardization of SPS and the ergonomics and operative characteristics inherent to SP access. The workshop incorporated expert presentations, panel discussions, formal voting, and simulator-based technical demonstrations to develop a conceptual, terminological, and ergonomic framework for SPS.

Conceptual and terminological framework

The first part of the workshop focused on the conceptual identity of SPS and the need for a common terminology. Participants discussed whether SPS should be defined primarily by a specific surgical technology or by the underlying mode of surgical access. Particular attention was given to the relationship among laparoscopic SPS, robotic SPS, and emerging technologies operating through a single access site.
Based on these discussions, SPS was conceptualized as a surgical platform rather than a specific device or technology. A hierarchical nomenclature based on Platform–System– Procedure was proposed to distinguish the fundamental access concept from the technological system used to perform surgery and the specific operation undertaken.
Terminology-related proposals were subsequently evaluated through formal voting. The use of “SP” rather than “LESS” as the preferred terminology was supported by 28 of 31 participants (90.3%). The Platform–System–Procedure hierarchy was supported by 30 of 32 participants (93.8%). For non-robotic SPS, the term “single-port laparoscopic” (SPL) was preferred by 21 of 30 participants (70.0%).
The classification of procedures involving additional ports was also discussed. Eighteen of 25 participants (72.0%) considered SPS to require no additional port. When an accessory port was used, the term “single-port surgery with an accessory port” may provide a transparent descriptive label, while acknowledging that the conceptual boundary between SPS and reduced-port surgery requires further discussion.
These discussions and voting results formed the basis of the K-SPS conceptual and nomenclature framework presented in this White Paper.

Ergonomic and operative framework

The second part of the workshop addressed the ergonomic and operative characteristics of SPS. Unlike conventional multiport laparoscopy, SPS requires the laparoscope and working instruments to converge through a single access site. This configuration creates distinctive geometric relationships among the access port, instruments, operative field, and surgeon.
Simulator-based demonstrations and structured discussions were used to examine variations in surgical posture and instrument manipulation. Particular attention was given to surgeon position, monitor position, table height, arm position, instrument arrangement within the access port, hand and instrument crossing, grip type, and the relationship between the surgeon’s forearm and the instrument axis.
The purpose of these discussions was not to define a single ideal posture or operative technique. Rather, the workshop sought to identify fundamental geometric and ergonomic variables that may explain variations in surgeon workload, technical efficiency, and reproducibility of SPS techniques.
These variables formed the basis of the ergonomic and operative framework proposed in this White Paper.
Simulator-session recordings were reviewed descriptively to identify recurring patterns in surgeon posture, port configuration, and instrument grip; no inferential comparisons or ergonomic superiority assessments were performed.

SPS AS A SURGICAL PLATFORM

From a surgical technique to a surgical platform

SPS has traditionally been described according to its most visible technical characteristic: the use of a single incision or access site. This description is intuitive but insufficient to encompass the diversity of technologies currently used to perform SPS. Laparoscopic instruments, robotic systems, and future surgical technologies may differ substantially in their hardware, control mechanisms, and surgeon interfaces while sharing the same fundamental access concept.
The K-SPS framework therefore conceptualizes SPS as a surgical platform defined by a single access site through which visualization and operative instruments are coordinated to perform surgery. In this context, the term platform refers to the fundamental surgical environment established by the access configuration rather than to a specific device, instrument, or commercial technology.
This access-based definition separates the identity of SPS from the technology used at a particular point in time. Conventional laparoscopic SPS and robotic SPS are therefore not competing definitions of SPS. Rather, they represent different technological implementations within the same surgical platform.
The concept of an inclusive single-site surgical framework is not entirely new. The 2010 consensus statement of the Laparoendoscopic Single-Site Surgery Consortium for Assessment and Research proposed a broad terminology intended to encompass laparoscopic, endoscopic, and robotic surgery performed through a single entry site [1]. However, subsequent technological development, particularly the emergence of dedicated robotic SP systems, has renewed the need to distinguish the underlying surgical concept from the system used to implement it.

Platform, system, and procedure

To provide a consistent structure for describing SPS, KSPS proposes a hierarchical nomenclature based on three levels: Platform → System → Procedure.
The platform defines the fundamental mode of surgical access. For example, the SP platform is characterized by the use of a single transabdominal access site for visualization and operative instrumentation, whereas vNOTES represents a natural-orifice access platform using the vagina as the primary route of surgical access.
The system describes the technological means by which surgery is performed within the platform. These include laparoscopic and robotic surgical systems. For robotic surgery, the specific commercial product or robotic model may be additionally specified in parentheses when relevant.
The procedure identifies the surgical operation performed, such as hysterectomy, myomectomy, or adnexal surgery.
Accordingly, SP and vNOTES can be distinguished at the platform level, whereas laparoscopic and robotic technologies represent systems through which surgery may be per-formed within a given platform.
The same surgical procedure may be performed using different systems within the SP platform. For example, hysterectomy may be performed using a laparoscopic or robotic system while remaining within the conceptual domain of SPS. The proposed Platform–System–Procedure hierarchy and examples of its application are illustrated in Fig. 2.
The proposed framework is not intended to replace established terminology. vNOTES, for example, is already a well-established term representing a distinct natural-orifice surgical platform and is therefore retained without modification [3].
This hierarchy is intended to prevent specific technologies or commercial product names from replacing the underlying surgical concept. It also provides a flexible nomenclature capable of accommodating future technologies without requiring repeated redefinition of SPS.

Technology evolves, platforms endure

Technological innovation has continuously changed the way minimally invasive surgery is performed. Instruments become articulated, visualization systems improve, and computer-assisted control systems increasingly mediate the interaction between the surgeon and the operative field. These developments may substantially alter the technical experience of surgery but do not necessarily redefine the underlying surgical platform.
Laparoscopic SPS is associated with technical limitations, including restricted instrument motion, external instrument collision, and limited intracorporeal triangulation [2]. Dedicated robotic SP systems address several of these constraints through articulated instrumentation and systemspecific instrument control [4]. Nevertheless, robotic technology did not create the concept of SPS. It represents a technological system designed to operate within the SP surgical platform.
Hybrid robotic surgery further illustrates the distinction between a surgical platform and the system used within it. In hybrid robotic SPS, laparoscopic and robotic techniques may be used sequentially during different steps of the same operation while maintaining the same SP access configuration [5]. The relative contribution of each system may vary according to the surgeon and operative strategy, supporting an access-based platform concept rather than a systembased definition of SPS.
Conversely, SPL surgery should not be regarded merely as an earlier or incomplete form of robotic SPS. It remains a distinct technological implementation of the same platform, with its own instrument geometry, surgeon–instrument interaction, workflow, and ergonomic characteristics.
The inclusion of vNOTES within the proposed framework further illustrates the distinction between platform and system. vNOTES is defined by its vaginal natural-orifice access route, whereas laparoscopic or robotic technologies may serve as the operative system used within that access platform. Thus, the same technological system may potentially be applied across distinct surgical platforms, reinforcing the need to describe access concept and surgical technology separately.
The distinction between platform and system is therefore fundamental to the K-SPS framework. Surgical systems will continue to evolve, and new technologies may emerge that differ substantially from both current laparoscopic and robotic systems. A platform-based conceptual framework allows these innovations to be described within a stable surgical language.

A COMMON LANGUAGE FOR SPS

Why a common language is needed

The evolution of SPS has been accompanied by considerable variation in terminology. Terms such as SPS, single-incision laparoscopic surgery, LESS, and SP access surgery have been used to describe overlapping surgical concepts. Although previous consensus efforts sought to establish a common terminology, variations in nomenclature have persisted as new surgical systems and technologies have emerged [1].
Inconsistent terminology creates practical problems beyond semantics. It complicates comparison between studies, limits the reproducibility of technical descriptions, and creates ambiguity in surgical education and communication. The increasing coexistence of laparoscopic and robotic systems within SPS further emphasizes the need for terminology that distinguishes the underlying surgical platform from the technology used to perform the operation.
The K-SPS nomenclature framework was therefore developed to provide a simple, technology-neutral, and extensible language for SPS.

K-SPS nomenclature principles

During the K-SPS Roadmap Workshop, terminology-related proposals were evaluated through formal voting. The use of SP rather than LESS as the preferred terminology was supported by 28 of 31 participants (90.3%). The proposed Platform–System–Procedure sequence for describing surgical procedures was supported by 30 of 32 participants (93.8%).
When referring to SPS performed using a laparoscopic system, SPL was preferred over the generic term SP by 21 of 30 participants (70.0%). Accordingly, K-SPS recommends that the surgical system be explicitly identified when necessary to distinguish laparoscopic and robotic approaches within the SP platform.
Under this framework, nomenclature should follow the sequence of platform, system, and procedure. For robotic procedures, the specific commercial product or robotic model may be included in parentheses when relevant. Examples of the proposed nomenclature are presented in Fig. 2.
The purpose of this nomenclature is not to replace every established procedural abbreviation currently used in clinical practice. Rather, it provides a consistent descriptive framework for scientific communication, education, and future multicenter research.

Additional access ports

The use of additional access ports presents a particular challenge in defining SPS. During the workshop, 18 of 25 participants (72.0%) considered procedures without any additional port to represent the boundaries of SPS, whereas six participants accepted one additional port and one participant accepted up to three additional ports.
For procedures in which an additional port is used, SPS with an accessory port was the most frequently preferred descriptive term, selected by 15 of 29 participants (51.7%). SP plus one was selected by nine participants, reduced-port surgery by five, and no participant selected hybrid SPS.

ERGONOMIC PATTERNS IN SPS

Ergonomic challenges in SPS

Ergonomic principles for minimally invasive surgery have been well described. A neutral head and neck position, limited shoulder abduction, appropriate elbow flexion, neutral wrist posture, and balanced weight distribution are generally recommended to reduce musculoskeletal strain during laparoscopic surgery [6,7]. Appropriate positioning of the monitor and operating table is also considered an important component of the ergonomic surgical environment [6,8].
SPS has frequently been associated with ergonomic limitations. The convergence of the laparoscope and working instruments through a single access site may result in instrument crowding, restricted range of motion, loss of triangulation, and non-neutral upper-extremity posture [2]. Previous studies have suggested increased surgeon workload and upper-extremity fatigue during single-incision surgery compared with conventional multiport laparoscopy, although the available evidence remains limited [9].
Despite these recognized limitations, the ergonomic strategies used by experienced SPS surgeons have not been systematically characterized. During the simulator session of the K-SPS Roadmap Workshop, substantial variation was observed in surgeon posture, port configuration, and instrument grip. These observations suggest that SPS is performed using multiple technical adaptations rather than a uniform ergonomic pattern.

Surgeon posture patterns

For the description of surgeon posture, the viewing axis was defined as the longitudinal direction from the SP access site toward the pelvic operative field, whereas the trunk axis was defined as the direction faced by the surgeon’s trunk.
Review of the simulator-session recordings revealed two recurring patterns of trunk orientation among 14 surgeons. For descriptive purposes, these patterns were classified as the perpendicular pattern and the rotated pattern (Fig. 3). Five surgeons demonstrated the perpendicular pattern and nine demonstrated the rotated pattern.
Posture was assessed from the caudal end of the simulator. The perpendicular pattern was defined when only the lateral profile of the surgeon's trunk was visible from this observation point. In this pattern, the trunk axis was approximately perpendicular to the viewing axis, forming an angle of approximately 90°, without apparent trunk rotation toward the viewing axis.
The rotated pattern was defined when the anterior surface of the surgeon’s trunk was visible from the same observation point. In this pattern, the surgeon rotated the trunk toward the viewing axis, reducing the angle between the trunk axis and the viewing axis to less than 90°.
These descriptive patterns demonstrate variation in trunk orientation among experienced SPS surgeons. Their ergonomic implications were not evaluated in the present analysis.

Port configuration patterns

Considerable variation was also observed in the arrangement of the laparoscope and working instruments within the SP access device. Six distinct port configuration patterns were identified through review of the simulator-session recordings (Fig. 4).
The relative positions of the laparoscope, right-hand instrument, and left-hand instrument differed among surgeons. These findings demonstrate that experienced SPS surgeons use diverse instrument arrangements within the same SP access configuration. The ergonomic and technical implications of these patterns remain to be determined.

Instrument grip patterns

Review of the simulator-session recordings also revealed variation in instrument grip. The right-hand instrument was consistently held using a conventional pistol grip. In contrast, two distinct grip patterns were observed for the lefthand instrument: a conventional pistol grip and a reverse grip (Fig. 5).
In the reverse grip, the orientation of the hand relative to the instrument handle differed from that of the conventional pistol grip. These observations were intended to characterize grip patterns rather than to determine the ergonomic superiority of either technique.
Collectively, the observed variations in surgeon posture, port configuration, and instrument grip demonstrate that SPS is performed using multiple ergonomic and technical patterns. Systematic characterization and objective comparison of these patterns will be necessary to identify reproducible and ergonomically sustainable approaches to SPS.

CONCLUSION AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS

SPS has continued to evolve with advances in laparoscopic and robotic technologies, yet its conceptual and technical language has remained fragmented. This White Paper proposes that SPS be understood primarily as a surgical platform defined by single-site access, rather than by a specific surgical system or commercial technology. Based on this concept, the Platform–System–Procedure hierarchy provides a simple and extensible framework for distinguishing surgical access platforms from the technological systems used within them and for describing SPS across current and future surgical technologies.
Observations from the K-SPS Roadmap Workshop further demonstrated substantial variability in surgeon posture, port configuration, and instrument grip. The patterns described in this paper are not intended to define an optimal technique or establish recommendations. Rather, they provide an initial descriptive framework for characterizing how SPS is currently performed by experienced surgeons.
Standardization should therefore begin with description before prescription. A common language is necessary to identify technical variation, compare different approaches, and determine which factors are relevant to surgeon ergonomics, surgical performance, and training. Future studies should systematically characterize SPS practice across a broader population of surgeons and evaluate the relationships among posture, port configuration, instrument grip, surgeon workload, and procedural performance.
The K-SPS framework presented here is intended as a starting point rather than a final standard. By establishing a shared conceptual and descriptive language, we hope to facilitate communication, education, and collaborative re-search and to provide a foundation for the future standardization of SPS.

Notes

Conflict of interest

No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.

Fig. 1.
The K-SPS Roadmap Workshop provided the basis for developing a common conceptual and descriptive framework for single-port surgery.
grs-2026-00045f1.jpg
Fig. 2.
The proposed Platform–System–Procedure hierarchy distinguishes the access platform, technological system, and surgical procedure within the nomenclature framework for single-port surgery.
grs-2026-00045f2.jpg
Fig. 3.
The simulator session demonstrated two surgeon posture patterns, including (A) the perpendicular pattern and (B) the rotated pattern.
grs-2026-00045f3.jpg
Fig. 4.
Port configuration patterns observed during the simulator session illustrate recurring variations in access-site layout and instrument arrangement.
grs-2026-00045f4.jpg
Fig. 5.
Instrument grip patterns observed in single-port surgery are shown as (A) the pistol grip and (B) the reverse grip used for the left-hand instrument.
grs-2026-00045f5.jpg

References

1. Gill IS, Advincula AP, Aron M, Caddedu J, Canes D, Curcillo PG 2nd, et al. Consensus statement of the consortium for laparoendoscopic single-site surgery. Surg Endosc 2010;24:762–8.
crossref pmid pdf
2. Tang B, Hou S, Cuschieri SA. Ergonomics of and technologies for single-port lapaxroscopic surgery. Minim Invasive Ther Allied Technol 2012;21:46–54.
crossref pmid
3. Kapurubandara S, Lowenstein L, Salvay H, Herijgers A, King J, Baekelandt J. Consensus on safe implementation of vaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (vNOTES). Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 2021;263:216–22.
crossref pmid
4. Massimello F, Cela V. Role of single port robotic surgery in gynecology. Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol 2024;95:102497.
crossref pmid
5. Won S, Lee N, Kim M, Kim MK, Kim ML, Jung YW, et al. Robotic single-site myomectomy: a hybrid technique reducing operative time and blood loss. Int J Med Robot 2020;16:e2061.
crossref pmid pdf
6. Supe AN, Kulkarni GV, Supe PA. Ergonomics in laparoscopic surgery. J Minim Access Surg 2010;6:31–6.
crossref pmid pmc
7. Yurteri-Kaplan LA, Park AJ. Surgical ergonomics and preventing work-related musculoskeletal disorders. Obstet Gynecol 2023;141:455–62.
crossref pmid
8. Berquer R, Smith WD, Davis S. An ergonomic study of the optimum operating table height for laparoscopic surgery. Surg Endosc 2002;16:416–21.
crossref pmid pdf
9. Koca D, Yıldız S, Soyupek F, Günyeli İ, Erdemoglu E, Soyupek S, et al. Physical and mental workload in single-incision laparoscopic surgery and conventional laparoscopy. Surg Innov 2015;22:294–302.
crossref pmid pdf
TOOLS
Share :
Facebook Twitter Linked In Google+ Line it
METRICS Graph View
  • 0 Crossref
  •    
  • 502 View
  • 10 Download
Related articles in Gyne Robot Surg


ABOUT
ARTICLE CATEGORY

Browse all articles >

BROWSE ARTICLES
EDITORIAL POLICY
AUTHOR INFORMATION
Editorial Office
Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Ewha Womans University Medical Center, 1071, Anyangcheon-ro, Yangcheon-gu, Seoul, Republic of Korea (07985)
Tel: +82-2-2650-5274    Fax: +82-2-2647-9860    E-mail: grsjournal.office@gmail.com                

Copyright © 2026 by Society of Korean Robotic Gynecologic Surgery.

Developed in M2PI

Close layer
prev next